As sad as it is, there needs to be focus on one way forward - that appears to be tabular. A migration path is needed, but having the two models is confusing and becoming unnecessary. Even if full support for MD features is not available I think this should still happen.
5 Comments
- pedro8New MemberThis is an extremely obtuse assertion. Multidimensional cubes are a different architecture which has its place in the enterprise and more often I find myself having to deploy both tabular and multidimensional models. Tabular has some advantages but it haves some serious limitations as well, and this is simply the way it is. In fact the more I use SSAS in tabular mode the more I find its limitations to be infuriating. One might as well say they want to deprecate pencils because of pens. If MSFT ever deprecated MD models they would be losing their competitive advantage to the likes of IBM and Oracle.
- Adrian_TheumaNew MemberI agree Pedro. I can't see this ever happening without Tabular first catching up to MD.
- fimianiNew MemberAgreed. There are a number of gaps that MD has that Tablular does not, and a few in the other direction as well. Tabular shortcomings when compared to MD: * write-back, * non-leaf writeback, * many-to-many, * unary operators, * several other critical things... Tabular upside compared to MD: * ability to on-the-fly model (add user-defined measures, dimension, granularities, hierarchies), * faster query times so I've heard, * other stuff? By no means an all-inclusive list. All that MS has to do is build out a gateway on top of MD that serves up the MD data as flattened Tabular slices, and there wouldn't be any issue here. Guess I'm just compelled to use Tableau until they get all of this resolved.
- pedro8New Member'@tf: Another serious limitation for me is the Direct query functionality of tabular models, which is meant to be analogous to ROLAP cubes. The fact is that when you turn direct query on, we get a severe set of limitations, which in my view makes Direct Query as useful as an ashtray on a motorbike :) For example we cannot use direct query when combining multiple data sources. This means that creating a tabular model to query line of business applications is inpractical since I cannot combine it with other data-sources, such as a date dimension from another DB.
- fbcideas_migusrNew MemberStatus added:New
Recent ideas
Power BI: Don't auto-SUM numeric data types
When setting column data type to numeric, Power BI defaults to automatically summing those columns. In real-world data most numeric data columns are not meant to be summed. They are sometimes primary...SevsBo2 minutes agoResponsive ResidentNew0Views0likes0CommentsPower BI: keep Transform button visible during initial data load, not hidden under Load button
With regular data ingestion it would be great if the Transform Data button wasn't hidden under the Load button. Any experienced Power BI developer will first do a data transformation, not merely load...SevsBo7 minutes agoResponsive ResidentNew1View0likes0CommentsCase sensitive-insensitive option in Power BI
There should be an option in Power BI for the data in the columns to be either case sensitive or insensitive. When one deals with data involving client names or entity names, case sensitivity-sinsens...sohail_syed_moh8 minutes agoNew MemberNeeds Votes2.3KViews127likes12Comments