Hit Reply to tell us what you think about the new On-Object Interaction feature so we can continue to improve.
-Power BI team
On Summary, the problems around on-object interaction as it is currently implemented are mostly around the panes and not really on-object interaction which is the main feature. While the interaction on PowerPoint and Excel is great, the panes that allow finer control are less accessible there, please don't go that way with Power BI too. We gotta have our panes.
I'll agree with the majority who are saying let us keep the old visualisation and data pane active while using On-Object. If we can use BOTH versions at the same time then this wouldn't be so bad, for me having to choose between having the Data pane active or the Formatting Pane active with a new intrusive sidebar that can't be hidden is a no go for me.
I get some people want to save on screen real estate but there's a good portion of us that need a lot of information on the screen, especially when OnObject doesn't show items with DAX errors well.
Having the visualizations over the right hand side was much better. Consider I'm working with complex measures that have quite long names, I expand out the visualizations pane on the right hand side and the data tab next to it and it makes everything visable and easy to read.
With the visualisations pane next to the chart of table in the middle of my screen I can't expand it out to be as large as it was on the side pane and i can't now ready my measure unless I hover the mouse over it, quite annoying. I prefer the old style.
Maybe the old and the new can be combined with having the visualizations tab on the right hand side stacked under the data tab.
Not a fan of this new feature at all. Blocks visuals, feels a bit clunky and does not add value in any way. For me, its made working a bit tougher as I have to break muscle memory with these changes and slows me down. But overall, I just fail to see the added value of this feature. There are orther things the PBI community has been asking for that would add much more value. Just my opinion.
As a trainer, I like to kick around new features before teaching them. When the March 2023 update brought On-Object Interaction, I tried it out. Initially, when I tried to move fields from one field well to another, I got an error message inviting me to report this to Microsoft, which I did. Today I built a report making a clustered column chart using the X axis and the legend. Again I swapped the fields and this time it didn't raise an error. However, when I clikcked on a column to filter other visuals by my selection, it didn't filter them; instead it took me to a data table view of my filtered figures, with a "Back to report" button.
It seems that if I create a visual, it filters as long as I don't edit the fields, but once I have done so, then it takes me to this data page. I have found this to be repeatable.
Please give us the option to have the on-visual formatting but retain the formatting, visualisation AND data panes. Whoever scoped this design clearly does not use the product.
While I am at it,
1. why cannot the app remember the width of the the panes? it is painful to keep resizing them.
2. why not make the build pane and fromat panes separate? or at least the option to separate them? We live in a world of ultra-wide screens nowadays 🙂
What changes would you like to see?
- I liked the Visualization pane where it was. We build muscle memory of selecting the visual and going back to the panes for everything and now I click on a visual and have to wait for the litle icon to show up. The new in-object pane shows up in different places, if it happens to be in a visual down on the page I have to scroll down - it really does now flow well - not to mention the extra clicks.
If you turned off the preview switch, why?
- It slowed me down, all reasons above
Any suggestions for addititional settings or capabilities?
- Provide the option to have the Visualization pane
The number one rule of software design is not to mess with what people know. Give us the option to still have a visualization pane. It takes many more clicks now than it used to with the visualization pane, like changing visual types, renaming fields, etc. The new user interface is not intuitive and needs work.
I turned off the The On-Object Interation feature after a few minutes of use. I hope that we are not forced to use it in the future.
The extra click to get/see the list of fields has no value. When the build 'menu' pops open and it is near the right hand side of the canvas, it covers up part of the visual that you are trying to modify. I noticed that the yellow warning triangle that is present when a column is no longer available is not shown in the 'build' panel.
The stacking of the Selection, bookmark, data... panels in the right side nav bar is nice though. My only thing that I dislike is the build menu and it's placement.
Thank you for the feedback and giving the preview a try. Can you share a screenshot of the first issue of the overlap? We are tracking a bug on the missing error state within the build menu.
When the visual is right next to the right edge of the canvis, the build a visual moves to the left, covering up part of the visual that you are attempting to change.
Loose analogy here:
If the data selection pane is akin to painter's color pallette, there is a reason why the color pallete's design allows for all color choices to be conveniently located and readily accessible.
The On-Object feature feels like we are taking the tubes of paint and putting them in our pocket. You need a different color? Take them out, find your color, put a dab on the canvas and then put them all back in your pocket again.
I tried it for a couple of days and am here typing this because when I changed it back, I noticed the "Share feedback" link.
Please do not force us to use this.
The last couple of changes to make PowerBI easier have made it progressively take more clicks for things.
To create a date slicer that was a dropdown used to only be three clicks.
1. Add date to page
2. Make visual a slicer
3. Click the ellipsis to change it to a dropdown
You then made it take extra clicks when you moved this functionality over to the visualizion pane.
In this new rendition of on object interaction you have made this same process take six clicks.
1. Add date to visual
2. Change visual type to slicer in object interaction (turn off suggest data type as it is always wrong)
3. Click the paintbrush
4. Click more options
5. Click slicer settings
6. Under options select dropdown style.
Stop trying to imitate Tableau. Updates to PowerBI UI should reduce number of clicks and simplify items. Not drastically increase and swap where things are ever UI update.
Exactly! We need less clicks, not more!
Also, the advantage of an old pane is that it's in FIXED position.
So in the old experience - my hand muscle memory easily remembers where to click and where to drag and drop.
In the new experience I need to concentrate hard to find that specific object's brush location, it can be anywhere on canvas and navigating there takes time and looses me concentration.
Please return the old pane experience
I have a dozen PBI reports, each report has a dozen pages, each page has 6+ visuals, each visual has 4+ data fields, imagine how many more clicks I will have to do now...
PBI strengths are its versitility, functionality, connectivity, service, high-power engine, dax language - simple, straightforward, powerful. It'd be great tragedy MS turns this into clustered bloated piece of software all under the false pretense of "making it easier to use".
I think it's promising but will have to get more used to it. I did notice what seems to be a bug in the combo chart, where I can not individually turn on/off data labels for line and column independently. If I turn off for line or column the data labels turns off completely.
Turned this preview feature off a few minutes after I turned it on. This has the feel of a feature that was designed by someone who does not use Power BI on the daily. It is counter-productive to 'nest' menus at this deep of level. This feature increased the number of clicks required to do some of the most common tasks. This feature could be okay if shortcut keys were more widely available. Please consider making this feature optional going forward and not a required default.
I switched back to the clasical mode for these reason.
1) you have to search for the button for each object. it's easier to look at the same place to see what are the data in the visual, than searching for the button and clicking it.
2) I didn't find how to reorganaise fields. (move up and down) drag and drop don't work
3) neither copy paste
4) the suggest format switch cannot be turned off once of all. Sorry but this is useless.
overall, I think that the most ennoying part is the 1). when you are using any software you are used to have functionnalities organised in your "workspace". Moving stuff from one fixed place to a moving one slows down the working process.
that's my 0.02€
Thank you for this feedback. We are looking into giving users the ability to attach the build menu as a pane again if you prefer the more static nature as before.
We're adding a few improvements for #2 here to make drag/drop zones a bit wider so super precision during dragging should not be required, however it should not be completely broken, would love to learn more about the visual type and which field wells you ran into this broken state. You can also right click on a field and use "move to" to swap which field well the field shows up in.
#3, are you saying copy/paste for a visual also stopped working for you? Could you share more details?
#4 you can set the suggestions to be off by default from the options menu if you prefer:
Check out the November 2023 Power BI update to learn about new features.
Read the latest Fabric Community announcements, including updates on Power BI, Synapse, Data Factory and Data Activator.
130+ sessions, 130+ speakers, Product managers, MVPs, and experts. All about Power BI and Fabric. Attend online or watch the recordings.