Hit Reply to tell us what you think about the new On-Object Interaction feature so we can continue to improve.
-Power BI team
The first thing I noticed as well in a very similar scenario!
You can get the top-level panes to display next to each other, but it requires additional clicks (not good UI) to access the 'feature', as shown below:
The problem I have with this new 'option' is that it's not a default setting we can at least control (in terms of the general UI behaviour), and if you've set up all of your panes and then accidentally click on the wrong object/icon, it will immediately revert back to single pane only (save the Filter).
If we could implement the 'Open in new pane' item as a permanent preference in the main settings (or in any way that would make it permanent/persistent in the application generally), that would go a long way to solving multiple issues with this new UI concept, but currently it feels like a somewhat fragile/temporary workaround rather than a robust option.
It feels like the feedback can be split into two distinct areas:
1) The functionality of the new feature
2) The original functionality that's been removed while it's turned on
Turning on the new feature shoud retain all the original functionality as well, so that it adds to the user experience, rather than just changing it... It seems that's why most people are turning it off as fast they're turning it on, without truely giving it a chance, because they prefer the old way... Which is quite normal... You might try mayo on your chips, but you'd still want a bit of ketchup.. at least the first few times
Knowing how users resist change, I did give it what I consider a decent try. I fought with it several days, forcing myself to explore and work with the new interface. In the end, I prefer the more efficient option (for me) of having all my desired panes open at once.
Been playing with the On-object Interaction for a while now and it breaks my heart to say that I am not a fan of the feature so far.
Having worked with PBI for over 6 years now, we have gotten used to the formatting pane being on the side and searching things in the pane itself.
I'd prefer having the flexibility to change the colors of the every data point, more or less like you can change the color of every cell in Excel.
Fomatting the table visual and matrix visual, still manages to be the most time consuming part of designing a dashboard.
Hoping to see the changes soon.
I like it... just one thing that i dont like is that options on the side of the object (like choose graphic) it stay over (in front) the DAX formula box when when you expand it. Probably a bug that will be fix... but ya just telling ;).... but i like it
After trying to work for hours with the position of the new visualization pane I turned it off. I'm fine with the panes icons in a veritical column, but build visualiztions and format should also stay visible as an icon to select on the right with the other icon selections, not next to the visualizations moving around as you add and re-size visualizations and trying to find it everytime I need it - wastes a lot time, easier to just go to the right and click on it.
I really do not like this change. There are some nice things about it, but not being able to easily see the visual type when I click on an object like before is not great. I also don't like the "on object" approach to adding/changing data in a visual. It is going to take me forever to do what was quick to do before. Please make this OPTIONAL and do not make it something that will be forced after preview.
I really like that I can edit the formatting of items in a visual while on the visual. Very convenient.
Not sure if these were mentioned but I would like to see the following:
Thank you for all the cool features that you folks keep adding.
One thing I just noticed is that it is more difficult to compare the configurations of differrent visuals with. I think the best aproach is to have the panes similar to the way they were and have the object editing functionality.
I find the previous layout mor eintuitive.
I have the same feeling. Maybe it will be a better idea to store user preferences on show/hide panes and to have a behavior similar to the slicers where you don't need ctrl for multiple selection. It was frustrating when selecting one pane knocked down another pane.
After a week with this feature - i dont like it. Can't see longer names when adding to fields. Nope! I wish an option for a 2nd screen and darkmode. This feature looks and feels like made by a person who has no experience with Power BI and UI design
I have disabled it after testing it. I don't think "on-object interaction" should be a mandatory option and the user should be allowed to choose the current form or this new one.
There's been a lot of negativity about this feature, and I don't disagree that yes, we need to be able to view simultaneous panes on the side just like before if we want to.
HOWEVER, let's not throw everything out the window. Much has been said about needing extra mouse clicks, needing to move the mouse further, etc. But some things are more efficient and intuitive with this feature.
So, while I agree with the need to return the panes, allowing us to drag and drop measures as before if we wish to, I would be sad to see some of these design elements go. PowerBI is notoriously less customizable than Excel, and part of that involves not being able to select individual objects on the graph. While this still doesn't allow us to, say, format a single data label in a specific color like you can in Excel, it's at least a step in the right direction.
I think On-Object has it's flaws and will need further tweaking, but that's the point of beta. The PowerBI team may not have hit a homer on the first swing, but neither have they struck out.
Check out Guy in a Cube on YouTube, he runs through how to get the panes back to the former layout while still utlizing the new feature.
One major issue with the "open in new pane" to show multiple panes is when you want to use a new pane from the menu it is a pain! It then replaces all the mutiple open panes with the new one. Not tested enough really
I run a BI development team with about fifteen developers, and they all agree that the new feature makes Power Bi feel more amateur and less geared towards professionals.
Pro devs use muscle memory of the eye and the hand/mouse to gain efficiency.
Previously all work was done in the menus on the right, and after a learning curve, the menus item locations could be memorized and hand and eye movement was minimized. This applied to all visuals, so no matter where the visual is, the developer knew where to find the format options.
Now the visual menu can be anywhere on the screen, and some of the options are still in the legacy many on the right.
Devs now have to search the screen with their eyes and mouse to find the tiny icon that could be anywhere on the screen and is in a different location for every visual. My team absolutely hates having to click all over the screen to accomplish what used to be in one menu on the right.
Not only that, we tested dozens of workflows, and every single one required more clicks. Sometimes up to triple the clicks for the same action.
There are a plethora of ideas from the community about improving Power Bi, but no one from the community was asking for half baked, partially developed on object interaction features. Really don't understand the motivation here - it breaks all previous training materials, makes the format feature far less efficient, and eliminated the ability to memorize where a feature will show up on the screen.
Perfect assessment. There seems to be a lack of consideration for the volume of report building being done, we don't need to get "cutesy" with it this far into the programs development. Keep it predictable and logical.
Check out the November 2023 Power BI update to learn about new features.
Read the latest Fabric Community announcements, including updates on Power BI, Synapse, Data Factory and Data Activator.
Join us for a free, hands-on Microsoft workshop led by women trainers for women where you will learn how to build a Dashboard in a Day!
130+ sessions, 130+ speakers, Product managers, MVPs, and experts. All about Power BI and Fabric. Attend online or watch the recordings.