Two visuals with same values and filtering settings show different results

I have two visuals using the same values, and filtering settings. The only thing that's different are that the two visuals are on two different pages. I was trying to find a way to debug this, and to see if I can get this resolved.

Both visuals are pulling from the same exact data, so it's not a data modeling issue. The data table has a "Total Reviews" and "Total Questions" data, which is being visualized on two separate tabs:

page1:

page2:

You'll notice that page2 numbers are down versus the page1 numbers. Also, I noticed the barchart for question volume for page2 is also different than the question volume for page1.

The underlying data for both of these visuals are the same exact data, so it's got to be a filtering issue at the page level. Moreover, when I look at the filters affecting each visual, and it comes up exactly the same for all visuals including the previous screenshots: (for simplicity, I did one screenshot here, but the other ones look exactly the same as this one)

page1 filters:

page2 filters:

I'm also looking at the Data/Drill tab, edit interactions, and am not finding any special filtering settings, I do feel stuck on what could be causing this issue. I'm almost certain that it's a page-level filter, but I don't know how else to debug it if the filtering looks the exact same for both, and I've only come across this issue with the most recent refresh (which means it wasn't an issue for 6 months until now).