Power BI is turning 10, and we’re marking the occasion with a special community challenge. Use your creativity to tell a story, uncover trends, or highlight something unexpected.
Get startedJoin us for an expert-led overview of the tools and concepts you'll need to become a Certified Power BI Data Analyst and pass exam PL-300. Register now.
Hi.
I have a table "DeviceList (2)" which has a column, [Device Name].
I would like (in Transform Data -> Add New Column) to look for the "Device List (2)"[Device Name] within the "Defender SNOW"[Short description] field and count how many results it finds.
The formula below is accepted in the Custom Column editor - but then shows as an error when viewing the table in PBI (see screenshot below the formula).
Any ideas what I may be doing wrong?
Thanks for any help,
Mark
if List.IsEmpty(
Table.SelectRows(
#"Defender SNOW",
(row) => Text.Contains(row[Short description], #"DeviceList (2)"[Device Name])
)
) then 0
else List.Count(
Table.SelectRows(
#"Defender SNOW",
(row) => Text.Contains(row[Short description], #"DeviceList (2)"[Device Name])
)
)
Solved! Go to Solution.
I think I have figured out your issue. It looks like you did not need the list functions as you could do the operations on the tables themselves. I think using the List function is what was causing the cyclical reference because as soon as I removed them they went away. Please see code below that I think solves your issue:
if Table.RowCount(Table.SelectRows(
#"Defender SNOW",
(row) => Text.Contains( row[Short description],[Device Name])
)) = 0
then 0
else Table.RowCount(Table.SelectRows(
#"Defender SNOW",
(row) =>Text.Contains( row[Short description],[Device Name])
))
If anyone else can provide a more techincal explanation for why this caused a cyclical reference, please feel free to add on.
Please mark as a solution if this worked for you!
If you click on the cell with one of the errors, what does the error message say? If you click in the grey area beside the "Error" hyperlink, it should show at the bottom of the screen.
Hi - it says:
Expression.Error: A cyclic reference was encountered during evaluation.
(I assume this is similar to a circular reference - but I can't see why).
Thanks, Mark
Thank you! Could you post the full Calculated column code?
Hi - yes:
= if List.IsEmpty(
Table.SelectRows(
#"Defender SNOW",
(row) => Text.Contains(row[Short description], #"DeviceList (2)"[Device Name])
)
) then 0
else List.Count(
Table.SelectRows(
#"Defender SNOW",
(row) => Text.Contains(row[Short description], #"DeviceList (2)"[Device Name])
)
)
I think I have figured out your issue. It looks like you did not need the list functions as you could do the operations on the tables themselves. I think using the List function is what was causing the cyclical reference because as soon as I removed them they went away. Please see code below that I think solves your issue:
if Table.RowCount(Table.SelectRows(
#"Defender SNOW",
(row) => Text.Contains( row[Short description],[Device Name])
)) = 0
then 0
else Table.RowCount(Table.SelectRows(
#"Defender SNOW",
(row) =>Text.Contains( row[Short description],[Device Name])
))
If anyone else can provide a more techincal explanation for why this caused a cyclical reference, please feel free to add on.
Please mark as a solution if this worked for you!
Hi - thank you so much - it does indeed work - although I have no explanation for it either 🙂
Cheers, Mark
This is your chance to engage directly with the engineering team behind Fabric and Power BI. Share your experiences and shape the future.
Check out the June 2025 Power BI update to learn about new features.
User | Count |
---|---|
72 | |
71 | |
57 | |
38 | |
36 |
User | Count |
---|---|
82 | |
67 | |
61 | |
46 | |
45 |