Forum Discussion

jppv20's avatar
jppv20
Icon for Solution Sage rankSolution Sage
3 years ago
Solved

Calculate Jaccard Similarity between two text strings

Hi,

 

I have a table with two columns containing a text string like this:

Name 1Name 2
Savoy SuitesSavoy Suites Hotel Apartments
NH Prague CityNH Prague City
Badhotel ScheveningenBadhotel Scheveningen
Terme Tuhelj en CampingTerme Tuhelj
Les Lauriers RosesBelambra Club Les Lauriers Roses
Nuovo Natural VillageNatural Village Resort
Torfhaus HarzresortTorfhaus Harzresort
Muenster Kongresscenter Affiliated by MeliaHotel Münster Kongresscenter Affiliated by Meliá
Royal Azur Thalasso GolfRoyal Azur Thalasso Golf
EperlandHotel Eperland

 

Is it possible creating a new column (or using a measure) to calculate the Jaccard Index for these two strings?

 

Thanks in advance!

 

Best,

Jori


Greg_Deckler 

  • Hi jppv20 

    If the pairs of strings are known in advance, I would say this task more suited to Power Query. You could create a custom function for Jaccard Similarity.

     

    However, it is interesting to look at doing this with DAX 🙂

     

    I have attached an example with a Jaccard Similarity calculated column (which could be adapted to a measure).

     

    I assumed that strings would be tokenized as words, delimited by spaces.  Does this match your methodolgy? If not, I'm sure it can be modified to suit.

     

    Here is the code for the calculated column:

    Jaccard Similarity = 
    VAR String1 = Data[Name 1]
    VAR String2 = Data[Name 2]
    -- Tokenize strings using space
    VAR Delimiter = " " 
    -- Convert to vertical bar delimiter to allow path functions
    VAR Bar = "|" 
    VAR String1_BarDelimited =
        SUBSTITUTE ( String1, Delimiter, Bar )
    VAR String1_TokenCount =
         PATHLENGTH ( String1_BarDelimited )
    VAR String2_BarDelimited =
        SUBSTITUTE ( String2, Delimiter, Bar )
    VAR String2_TokenCount =
         PATHLENGTH ( String2_BarDelimited )
    VAR String1_Tokens =
        SELECTCOLUMNS (
            GENERATESERIES ( 1, String1_TokenCount ),
            "Token", PATHITEM ( String1_BarDelimited, [Value] )
        )
    VAR String2_Tokens =
        SELECTCOLUMNS (
            GENERATESERIES ( 1, String2_TokenCount ),
            "Token", PATHITEM ( String2_BarDelimited, [Value] )
        )
    -- DAX INTERSECT function preserves duplicates so is suitable to find intersection
    VAR Tokens_Intersection =
        INTERSECT ( String1_Tokens, String2_Tokens )
    -- DAX UNION function not suitable as it is equivalent to SQL UNION ALL
    -- First get distinct union of tokens from both strings
    VAR Tokens_Union_Distinct =
        DISTINCT ( UNION ( String1_Tokens, String2_Tokens ) )
    -- Then repeat each token the max number of times it appears in each string
    VAR Tokens_Union =
        SELECTCOLUMNS (
            GENERATE (
                Tokens_Union_Distinct,
                VAR CurrentToken = [Token]
                VAR String1_Count =
                    COUNTROWS ( FILTER ( String1_Tokens, [Token] = CurrentToken ) )
                VAR String2_Count =
                    COUNTROWS ( FILTER ( String2_Tokens, [Token] = CurrentToken ) )
                VAR Max_Count =
                    MAX ( String1_Count, String2_Count )
                RETURN
                    -- create required number of rows
                    GENERATESERIES ( 1, Max_Count ) 
            ),
            "Token", [Token]
        )     
    VAR Jaccard =
        DIVIDE (
            COUNTROWS ( Tokens_Intersection ),
            COUNTROWS ( Tokens_Union )
        )
    RETURN
        Jaccard

    One thing to note is that the DAX UNION function is similar to UNION ALL in SQL, so we need to modify its result to ensure each token is repeated the correct number of times (the max occurrences in any one of the strings).

     

    Regards

6 Replies

  • Hi jppv20 

    If the pairs of strings are known in advance, I would say this task more suited to Power Query. You could create a custom function for Jaccard Similarity.

     

    However, it is interesting to look at doing this with DAX 🙂

     

    I have attached an example with a Jaccard Similarity calculated column (which could be adapted to a measure).

     

    I assumed that strings would be tokenized as words, delimited by spaces.  Does this match your methodolgy? If not, I'm sure it can be modified to suit.

     

    Here is the code for the calculated column:

    Jaccard Similarity = 
    VAR String1 = Data[Name 1]
    VAR String2 = Data[Name 2]
    -- Tokenize strings using space
    VAR Delimiter = " " 
    -- Convert to vertical bar delimiter to allow path functions
    VAR Bar = "|" 
    VAR String1_BarDelimited =
        SUBSTITUTE ( String1, Delimiter, Bar )
    VAR String1_TokenCount =
         PATHLENGTH ( String1_BarDelimited )
    VAR String2_BarDelimited =
        SUBSTITUTE ( String2, Delimiter, Bar )
    VAR String2_TokenCount =
         PATHLENGTH ( String2_BarDelimited )
    VAR String1_Tokens =
        SELECTCOLUMNS (
            GENERATESERIES ( 1, String1_TokenCount ),
            "Token", PATHITEM ( String1_BarDelimited, [Value] )
        )
    VAR String2_Tokens =
        SELECTCOLUMNS (
            GENERATESERIES ( 1, String2_TokenCount ),
            "Token", PATHITEM ( String2_BarDelimited, [Value] )
        )
    -- DAX INTERSECT function preserves duplicates so is suitable to find intersection
    VAR Tokens_Intersection =
        INTERSECT ( String1_Tokens, String2_Tokens )
    -- DAX UNION function not suitable as it is equivalent to SQL UNION ALL
    -- First get distinct union of tokens from both strings
    VAR Tokens_Union_Distinct =
        DISTINCT ( UNION ( String1_Tokens, String2_Tokens ) )
    -- Then repeat each token the max number of times it appears in each string
    VAR Tokens_Union =
        SELECTCOLUMNS (
            GENERATE (
                Tokens_Union_Distinct,
                VAR CurrentToken = [Token]
                VAR String1_Count =
                    COUNTROWS ( FILTER ( String1_Tokens, [Token] = CurrentToken ) )
                VAR String2_Count =
                    COUNTROWS ( FILTER ( String2_Tokens, [Token] = CurrentToken ) )
                VAR Max_Count =
                    MAX ( String1_Count, String2_Count )
                RETURN
                    -- create required number of rows
                    GENERATESERIES ( 1, Max_Count ) 
            ),
            "Token", [Token]
        )     
    VAR Jaccard =
        DIVIDE (
            COUNTROWS ( Tokens_Intersection ),
            COUNTROWS ( Tokens_Union )
        )
    RETURN
        Jaccard

    One thing to note is that the DAX UNION function is similar to UNION ALL in SQL, so we need to modify its result to ensure each token is repeated the correct number of times (the max occurrences in any one of the strings).

     

    Regards

      • OwenAuger's avatar
        OwenAuger
        Icon for Super User rankSuper User

        Hi eliasayyy 

        No problem, updated PBIX attached.

         

        1. The measure is quite similar to the calculated column. However, to provide input to the measure, I created two disconnected tables containing strings ('Name 1' and 'Name 2').
        2. For Power Query I created a function. The code is significantly shorter than the DAX version, since Power Query has more convenient text-splitting functions, and the List.Union function gives us the result we need directly.

        There may be some special cases to handle in both methods (empty strings etc) but this is at least a start 🙂

         

        Code below.

        Regards,

        Owen

         

        Measure: Jaccard Similarity Measure

        VAR String1 = SELECTEDVALUE ( 'Name 1'[Name 1] )
        VAR String2 = SELECTEDVALUE ( 'Name 2'[Name 2] )
        RETURN
        IF (
            NOT ISBLANK ( String1 ) && NOT ISBLANK ( String2 ),
            -- Tokenize strings using space
            VAR Delimiter = " " 
            -- Convert to vertical bar delimiter to allow path functions
            VAR Bar = "|" 
            VAR String1_BarDelimited =
                SUBSTITUTE ( String1, Delimiter, Bar )
            VAR String1_TokenCount =
                PATHLENGTH ( String1_BarDelimited )
            VAR String2_BarDelimited =
                SUBSTITUTE ( String2, Delimiter, Bar )
            VAR String2_TokenCount =
                PATHLENGTH ( String2_BarDelimited )
            VAR String1_Tokens =
                SELECTCOLUMNS (
                    GENERATESERIES ( 1, String1_TokenCount ),
                    "Token", PATHITEM ( String1_BarDelimited, [Value] )
                )
            VAR String2_Tokens =
                SELECTCOLUMNS (
                    GENERATESERIES ( 1, String2_TokenCount ),
                    "Token", PATHITEM ( String2_BarDelimited, [Value] )
                )
            -- DAX INTERSECT function preserves duplicates so is suitable to find intersection
            VAR Tokens_Intersection =
                INTERSECT ( String1_Tokens, String2_Tokens )
            -- DAX UNION function not suitable as it is equivalent to SQL UNION ALL
            -- First get distinct union of tokens from both strings
            VAR Tokens_Union_Distinct =
                DISTINCT ( UNION ( String1_Tokens, String2_Tokens ) )
            -- Then repeat each token the max number of times it appears in each string
            VAR Tokens_Union =
                SELECTCOLUMNS (
                    GENERATE (
                        Tokens_Union_Distinct,
                        VAR CurrentToken = [Token]
                        VAR String1_Count =
                            COUNTROWS ( FILTER ( String1_Tokens, [Token] = CurrentToken ) )
                        VAR String2_Count =
                            COUNTROWS ( FILTER ( String2_Tokens, [Token] = CurrentToken ) )
                        VAR Max_Count =
                            MAX ( String1_Count, String2_Count )
                        RETURN
                            -- create required number of rows
                            GENERATESERIES ( 1, Max_Count ) 
                    ),
                    "Token", [Token]
                )
                        
            VAR Jaccard =
                DIVIDE (
                    COALESCE ( COUNTROWS ( Tokens_Intersection ), 0 ),
                    COUNTROWS ( Tokens_Union )
                )
            RETURN
                Jaccard
        )

         

        Power Query function: fn_JaccardSimilarity

        ( String1 as text, String2 as text ) as number =>
        let
            String1_Tokens = Text.Split(String1, " "),
            String2_Tokens = Text.Split(String2, " "),
            Intersection = List.Intersect({String1_Tokens,String2_Tokens}),
            Union = List.Union({String1_Tokens,String2_Tokens}),
            Intersection_Count = List.Count(Intersection),
            Union_Count = List.Count(Union),
            Jaccard_Similarity = Intersection_Count / Union_Count
        in Jaccard_Similarity

         

    • Karthik_s3's avatar
      Karthik_s3
      Regular Visitor

      Hi 

      Good evening.  

      Your solution was awesome.  Thanks a lot.  This formula works like magic.  It has saved me lot of time and effort. 

      Thanks. 

      Karthik