cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Fabric is Generally Available. Browse Fabric Presentations. Work towards your Fabric certification with the Cloud Skills Challenge.

Reply
MoeData
Advocate II
Advocate II

Applying multiple filters on table (with the goal of avoiding repeated filters)

I have a report with slow visuals (to the point that it runs out of memory) and I am trying to optimize some of the DAX measures. 

It is a big report, but the model for the part that I am having problems has 4 tables shown below:

Model.png

and the current measure is:

 

Capacity  = (CALCULATE(SUM(FactCapacityForecast[Value]),
                            FILTER('Shared DW_DimVersion', EDATE(MIN(DimDate[Date]),-1)='Shared DW_DimVersion'[FCStartDate]),
                           	FILTER('Shared DW_DimAccount','Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]="CALC0008"),
                            DATESBETWEEN(DimDate[Date],MIN(DimDate[Date]),EDATE(min(DimDate[Date]),5)))
                        +
                      CALCULATE(SUM(FactCapacityForecast[Value]),
                            FILTER('Shared DW_DimVersion', EDATE(MIN(DimDate[Date]),-1)='Shared DW_DimVersion'[FCStartDate]),
                           	FILTER('Shared DW_DimAccount','Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]="CALC0006"),
                            DATESBETWEEN(DimDate[Date],MIN(DimDate[Date]),EDATE(min(DimDate[Date]),5))))
                      *
                      (DIVIDE(
                        CALCULATE(SUM(FactCapacityForecast[Value]),
                            FILTER('Shared DW_DimVersion', EDATE(MIN(DimDate[Date]),-1)='Shared DW_DimVersion'[FCStartDate]),
                            FILTER('Shared DW_DimAccount','Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]="CALC0017"),
                            DATESBETWEEN(DimDate[Date],MIN(DimDate[Date]),EDATE(min(DimDate[Date]),5))),
                        CALCULATE(SUM(FactCapacityForecast[Value]),
                            FILTER('Shared DW_DimVersion', EDATE(MIN(DimDate[Date]),-1)='Shared DW_DimVersion'[FCStartDate]),
                            FILTER('Shared DW_DimAccount','Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]="CALC0016"),
                            DATESBETWEEN(DimDate[Date],MIN(DimDate[Date]),EDATE(min(DimDate[Date]),5)))))
                      *
                        (DIVIDE(
                        CALCULATE(SUM(FactCapacityForecast[Value]),
                            FILTER('Shared DW_DimVersion', EDATE(MIN(DimDate[Date]),-1)='Shared DW_DimVersion'[FCStartDate]),
                            FILTER('Shared DW_DimAccount','Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]="CALC0005"),
                            DATESBETWEEN(DimDate[Date],MIN(DimDate[Date]),EDATE(min(DimDate[Date]),5))),
                        CALCULATE(SUM(FactCapacityForecast[Value]),
                            FILTER('Shared DW_DimVersion', EDATE(MIN(DimDate[Date]),-1)='Shared DW_DimVersion'[FCStartDate]),
                            FILTER('Shared DW_DimAccount','Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]="CALC0006"),
                            DATESBETWEEN(DimDate[Date],MIN(DimDate[Date]),EDATE(min(DimDate[Date]),5))))*-1)*-1

 


I believe this can be written in a more efficient and readable way. Right now the filters are applied on 3 tables ('Shared DW_DimVersion', 'Shared DW_DimAccount' and 'DimDate') in each of CALCULATE functions and 2 of those are just being repeated. I want to create a table variable where I first apply filters on 'Shared DW_DimVersion' and 'DimDate' only once and then use that variable to apply filter on 'Shared DW_DimAccount' afterwards. 

Maybe the final measure can be something like this:

Capacity Optimized = 
                       VAR intermediate_table =
                        CALCULATETABLE(FactCapacityForecast,
                            //KEEPFILTERS(
                                FILTER(
                                //ALL ('Shared DW_DimVersion'[FCStartDate]),
                                'Shared DW_DimVersion',
                                EDATE(MIN('DimDate'[Date]),-1)='Shared DW_DimVersion'[FCStartDate]
                                )
                            //    )
                                ,
                            KEEPFILTERS(    DATESBETWEEN(DimDate[Date],MIN(DimDate[Date]),EDATE(min(DimDate[Date]),5))
                            )
                            //DATESINPERIOD('DimDate'[Date],MIN('DimDate'[Date]), 5, MONTH)
                            )

                        RETURN
                        (CALCULATE(SUMX(intermediate_table, FactCapacityForecast[Value]), 
                            KEEPFILTERS(
                            FILTER(
                                //ALL ('Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]),
                                'Shared DW_DimAccount',
                                'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0008"
                                )
                            )
                        ) 
                        +
                        CALCULATE(SUMX(intermediate_table, FactCapacityForecast[Value]), 
                            KEEPFILTERS(
                            FILTER(
                                //ALL ('Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]),
                                'Shared DW_DimAccount',
                                'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0006"
                                )
                            )
                        ))
                        *
                        DIVIDE(
                            CALCULATE(SUMX(intermediate_table, FactCapacityForecast[Value]), 
                            KEEPFILTERS(
                            FILTER(
                                //ALL ('Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]),
                                'Shared DW_DimAccount',
                                'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]  = "CALC0017"
                                )
                            )
                        ),
                            CALCULATE(SUMX(intermediate_table, FactCapacityForecast[Value]), 
                            KEEPFILTERS(
                                FILTER(
                                //ALL ('Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]),
                                'Shared DW_DimAccount',
                                'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0016"
                                )
                            )
                            )
                        )
                        *
                        (DIVIDE(
                            CALCULATE(SUMX(intermediate_table, FactCapacityForecast[Value]), 
                            KEEPFILTERS(
                            FILTER(
                                ALL ('Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]),
                                'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0005"
                                )
                            )
                        ),
                            CALCULATE(SUMX(intermediate_table, FactCapacityForecast[Value]), 
                            KEEPFILTERS(
                            FILTER(
                                ALL ('Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber]),
                                'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0006"
                                )
                            )
                            )
                        )*-1)*-1


The results are supposed to be used in a matrix alongside 'DimDate[Month]' values. 
I have been playing around with different functions, but cannot get the same number as the original measure. 
How can I get the correct measure?

Thanks!
Moe



@OwenAuger I think you have a good solution for this problem as well 😄 

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION
tamerj1
Super User
Super User

Hi @MoeData 

please try

Capacity =
VAR MinDate =
    MIN ( DimDate[Date] )
VAR DimVersion =
    FILTER (
        'Shared DW_DimVersion',
        'Shared DW_DimVersion'[FCStartDate] = EDATE ( MinDate, -1 )
    )
VAR Dates =
    DATESBETWEEN ( DimDate[Date], MinDate, EDATE ( MinDate, 5 ) )
VAR FactCapacity =
    CALCULATETABLE ( FactCapacityForecast, DimVersion, Dates )
VAR CALC0005 =
    CALCULATE (
        SUM ( FactCapacityForecast[Value] ),
        FactCapacity,
        'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0005"
    )
VAR CALC0006 =
    CALCULATE (
        SUM ( FactCapacityForecast[Value] ),
        FactCapacity,
        'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0006"
    )
VAR CALC0008 =
    CALCULATE (
        SUM ( FactCapacityForecast[Value] ),
        FactCapacity,
        'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0008"
    )
VAR CALC0016 =
    CALCULATE (
        SUM ( FactCapacityForecast[Value] ),
        FactCapacity,
        'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0016"
    )
VAR CALC0017 =
    CALCULATE (
        SUM ( FactCapacityForecast[Value] ),
        FactCapacity,
        'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0017"
    )
RETURN
    ( CALC0008 + CALC0006 )
        * ( DIVIDE ( CALC0017, CALC0016 ) )
        * ( DIVIDE ( CALC0005, CALC0006 ) * -1 ) * -1

 

 

View solution in original post

2 REPLIES 2
MoeData
Advocate II
Advocate II

@tamerj1 Amazing! Thanks! Runs faster and much more readable.

tamerj1
Super User
Super User

Hi @MoeData 

please try

Capacity =
VAR MinDate =
    MIN ( DimDate[Date] )
VAR DimVersion =
    FILTER (
        'Shared DW_DimVersion',
        'Shared DW_DimVersion'[FCStartDate] = EDATE ( MinDate, -1 )
    )
VAR Dates =
    DATESBETWEEN ( DimDate[Date], MinDate, EDATE ( MinDate, 5 ) )
VAR FactCapacity =
    CALCULATETABLE ( FactCapacityForecast, DimVersion, Dates )
VAR CALC0005 =
    CALCULATE (
        SUM ( FactCapacityForecast[Value] ),
        FactCapacity,
        'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0005"
    )
VAR CALC0006 =
    CALCULATE (
        SUM ( FactCapacityForecast[Value] ),
        FactCapacity,
        'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0006"
    )
VAR CALC0008 =
    CALCULATE (
        SUM ( FactCapacityForecast[Value] ),
        FactCapacity,
        'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0008"
    )
VAR CALC0016 =
    CALCULATE (
        SUM ( FactCapacityForecast[Value] ),
        FactCapacity,
        'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0016"
    )
VAR CALC0017 =
    CALCULATE (
        SUM ( FactCapacityForecast[Value] ),
        FactCapacity,
        'Shared DW_DimAccount'[AccountNumber] = "CALC0017"
    )
RETURN
    ( CALC0008 + CALC0006 )
        * ( DIVIDE ( CALC0017, CALC0016 ) )
        * ( DIVIDE ( CALC0005, CALC0006 ) * -1 ) * -1

 

 

Helpful resources

Announcements
PBI November 2023 Update Carousel

Power BI Monthly Update - November 2023

Check out the November 2023 Power BI update to learn about new features.

Community News

Fabric Community News unified experience

Read the latest Fabric Community announcements, including updates on Power BI, Synapse, Data Factory and Data Activator.

Power BI Fabric Summit Carousel

The largest Power BI and Fabric virtual conference

130+ sessions, 130+ speakers, Product managers, MVPs, and experts. All about Power BI and Fabric. Attend online or watch the recordings.

Top Solution Authors
Top Kudoed Authors