ALL function not behaving as expected

[_Regina]

Hi everyone,

I have the following measure. What I am trying to do here is get the number of distinct 'onboarding ids' where there is a transaction.

Onboarding ID is in a fact table named 'Onbaording requests', transactions are in a fact table name 'Sales transactions'. Both these tables have a common column 'ACCOUNT_DIM_SYSID'.

Both the fact tables have relation with 'Date' table.

'Onbaording requests'[start date] to Date[Date]

'Sales transactions'[transaction dtae] to to Date[Date]

I have used NATURALINNERJOIN to obtain the result. The only thing is that I don't want the date slicer to affect Sales transactions, it should only affect 'Onboarding requests' table. I have a date slicer on my report page which is based on Dtae table.

For ex:

If I choose June 2023, It should give me all 'onboarding id' that have start date in June 2023 and have an associated transaction, even if the transaction occured outside of June 2023. 

I have used ALL function in my variable b., but it still giving me all onboarding id where start date is in June 2023 as well as Transaction Dtae is in June 2023.

_test =
VAR a =
       SELECTCOLUMNS (
                'Onboarding Requests',
                "ACCOUNT_DIM_SYSID", 'Onboarding Requests'[ACCOUNT_SYSID] + 0,
                "onboarding_id", 'Onboarding Requests'[ONBOARDING_ID]
         )
VAR b =
      SELECTCOLUMNS (
             FILTER (
                    ALL ( 'Sales Transactions'[ACCOUNT_DIM_SYSID] ),
                   [_Product Net Sales Buy Sell Transaction Count] > 0
             ),
            "ACCOUNT_DIM_SYSID", 'Sales Transactions'[ACCOUNT_DIM_SYSID] + 0
       )
VAR R =
             NATURALINNERJOIN ( a, b )
VAR result =
             COUNTROWS ( SUMMARIZE ( R, [onboarding_id] ) )
RETURN
           result

Any guidance here is appreciated. @amitchandak @AlexisOlson 

[AlexisOlson · Accepted solution]

The measure [_Product Net Sales Buy Sell Transaction Count] still has the date filter context active.

Maybe removing the date filtering in the definition of b will help.

VAR b =
    SELECTCOLUMNS (
        CALCULATETABLE (
            FILTER (
                ALL ( 'Sales Transactions'[ACCOUNT_DIM_SYSID] ),
                [_Product Net Sales Buy Sell Transaction Count] > 0
            ),
            ALL ( 'Date' )
        ),
        "ACCOUNT_DIM_SYSID", 'Sales Transactions'[ACCOUNT_DIM_SYSID] + 0
    )