Creating a column with two tables (one with repeated values)

Hello guys, 

I Have two tables, Table 1 with main data (dimension table), and Table 2 with repeated values (fact):

Table 1

Table 2

I'm trying to create a new column in Table 1 getting infortmations of Table 2 like this:

- If there are any informations about an item, then "Already made contact".

- If there isn't any information, I would like to get "No contact".

I tried to use dax to create a column like this:  

IF(LOOKUPVALUE(Table2[STATUS], Table2[ITEM], Table1[ITEM]) = "", "No contact", "Already made contact")

but I get an error saying "A table of multiple values was supplied where a single value was expected".

The table 1 would like to get is like:

Is there another way to get this?