Forum Discussion

Anske's avatar
Anske
Frequent Visitor
6 years ago

Query folding for Redshift

Please help, I though as mentioned in Query folding with Amazon Web Services  that query folding is supported for Redshift, but when I'm trying to check the steps that apply query folding in the query editor by right mouse-clicking the steps, 'View Native Query' is greyed out at each and every steps, even the first initial steps of remove columns. 

Am I mistaken in thinking query folding is supported for Redshift?

 

Thanks,

Need Help

4 Replies

  • dax's avatar
    dax
    Icon for Community Support rankCommunity Support
    6 years ago

    Hi Anske, 

    In the link, it didn't mention that the Redshit supoort query foldering. Most data sources that have the concept of a query language support query folding. These data sources can include relational databases, OData feeds (including SharePoint lists), Exchange, and Active Directory. However, data sources like flat files, blobs, and web typically do not.

    In addition, in the Power Query Editor window, it is possible to determine when a Power Query query can be folded. In the Query Settings pane, when you right-click the last applied step, if the View Native Query option is enabled (not greyed out), then the query can be folded. You siad that the option is greyed out, so I think Redshift doesn't support it.

    Best Regards,
    Zoe Zhi

    If this post helps, then please consider Accept it as the solution to help the other members find it more quickly.

    • Anske's avatar
      Anske
      Frequent Visitor
      6 years ago

      For all the other people trying to find out, the answer is, Redshift does not support query folding, unfortunately. 

      The other thing is, when using power BI service, the range of IP adresses is too long to whitelist for your Redshift cluster. 

      My advice would be, consider using another front-end tool when your data is in Redshift :-).

       

       

  • scramiro's avatar
    scramiro
    New Member
    1 year ago

    I have the same question.

    I checked the video, and as the Diagnose Step tool does not provide a "GetResponse Stream", it means it does not support query folding. However, If I run the same steps in Data Flows, the icons in the steps indicates and yes It is folding. Alos, If I set up incremental refresh on the data flow, it allows it, meaning, it allows folding. Finally, Microsoft Learn states Redshift allows Query Folding. 

    So I bit confusing... dataflows indicates yes, desktop not. None offers the "native query".

     

    It is said here by Anske that it does not support folding, but I would like to see evidence.

     

    Regards.

     

    Regards.