Hit Reply to tell us what you think about the new On-Object Interaction feature so we can continue to improve.
-Power BI team
Hi @JonasArnout2 thanks for taking the time to write this feedback. We have 2 features for pinning panes and a setting for always "open in new pane" on it's way!
In the interim, you can open multiple panes side by side by CTRL + Click or right click "open in new pane."
Have you had a chance to use the new on-object formatting capabilities? Would love your thoughts on that as a long time user of Power BI, we hope the formatting is easier with the point and click.
Hello, aggregations are still available on right click of a field, or you can use the flyout menu that contains the aggregations dropdown when choosing or swapping a field:
Power BI should be accessible and useful to "citizen developers" as "self-service BI" for people who only spend a limited portion of their time working in Power BI. When you require right clicks and the Ctrl key and hide menu items, etc, it severely increases the learning curve and discourages use of the product by non-developers.
Not a fan of this feature, It seems like you're messing with a good thing. If you do go forward with this, will you please leave it as a optional feature so that I don't have to use it in desktop if I dont want to?
Have tried this for a few months but its just horrible, the on object box gets in the way of other visuals/selection areas, doesnt always stick, is bad for interaction and the "format" select tool no longer sticks as noted here https://community.fabric.microsoft.com/t5/Desktop/Format-Button-not-sticking/m-p/3334364#M1112624
Have reverted back to the original, so much better, easier to use and quicker
I really tried. Really. I gave it a third and then a forth try. In May, Jun and July.
And I just hate the experience. I am clicking all over the place. It is sooo confusing.
Please, RETURN OUR PREVIOUS EXPERIENCE.
Not because we are used to it, but because the new SUCKS.
We want a data pane and next to it ONE pane that has both: formatting options AND field places for a visual.
If you want to add other stuff to visuals - do it, but don't hurt what is working excellent.
I turn the feature off. Again
Thanks for trying out the preview. Apologies that it is making it harder for you to use the product. It is taking some time to finish the work so there is flexibility when using the menus and their placement. You may want to wait a few releases to try the preview again. Each incremental update is building to make the feature better, but it is taking time to implement.
I know you have taken a lot of time with this preview already, but if I can ask a favor of you to check this out again in Oct. There should be more options for you at that time. Please feel free to try out any of the releases until then if you would like though. Your feedback is always appreciated.
Thanks for trying out the preview. We're trying to get the updates out as quickly as possible, though there is more work to be done. The Sept and Oct releases will give you more flexibility on the size and placement of the menus. Hopefully you will continue to try this out in a later release to let us know if these solutions work for you.
Thanks for the feedback. We are working to make the menus easier to use. Until all the menu features are complete you can add multiple drill-through parameters by using the pane switcher. With the Data pane open you can right-click on the Format icon and select open in new pane or you can Ctrl+click the Format icon. This will open the panes next to each other.
If you don't have both the Data and Format panes in the pane switcher you can select both of them from the View tab of the ribbon here
We will be making the menus easier to use in our Sept and Oct releases. I hope you will continue to try the preview and let us know your feedback.
First of all thanks for your constant great job.
But I am not a big fan of the current version of that feature and I switched it off after working a week with it.
The feature ultimately increased the time for me setting up data. It decreased time while styling visuals. Overall it lead to more clicks, more time, and didnt impact my workflow in a significantly positive way. But it doesnt mean the feature is generally bad.
You may wonder why that is.
I love the to have multiple panes next to each other. It provides a great overview without clicking between several settings. Even while working at the big screen it is no trouble. Especially the data pane right next to the visualization pane is great. I can simply drag and drop data into the visual. The new version feels more restrictive. I have to click between settings. I loose the overall overview. There are little search areas. I have to remember data fields more often etc. It is just less convenient.
I noticed a similar structure on other products (power point for instance) and it just gives you LESS overview because a user has to click between settings. I have to constantly click between visualization and data pane. This makes me crazy.
What I like about the new on-object interaction
It makes editing simple and a little more intuitive. BUT setting up a visual feels more complicated...way more complicated.
What would be my preferred solution
A mixture of would be cool. I want to have the option to have the panes next to each other but also want to be able adjust settings while double clicking in a chart etc.
So please, really do something about it.
Thank you for the feedback. We will be adding my flexibility in the menus in the upcoming Sept and Oct releases. You'll also be able keep the panes you would like to open, so the next time you come to Power BI you won't have to open the menus again. For the time being if you want to work with panes next to each other you can use the open in new pane option or Ctrl+click on the pane you would like to open next to each other
I hope you will continue to try the later releases and let us know if the improvements are helping.
I agree with you raymondpocher, I also always end up turning on the feature to analyze the news and in a short time of use I disable it and go back to the previous default, because my work needs to render and the new feature only delays the progress of the work a lot with so many additional clicks. I liked several things about this new feature that can be added to the current standard, such as the "Visualizations" tab being able to collapse the "Buid visual" panel to expand the values detailing area, and others like editing the title directly in the visual, but I reiterate that these features should be additional to the standard and not replacing it.
Tested again today with the latest release and very quickly reverted back to the 'old' interaction due to time lost, but there has been some positive progress (thank you!), however what I now refer to as the 'main issue' (for myself and many other users as mentioned below) still remains.
Updated feedback (in more detail) follows:
The new updates as of this month (July 20th at time of writing) do improve the situation, but the same fundamental issue remains, as stated above.
To summarise the main (remaining) requirement:
With these changes (or a single change if simplified as: make all right-hand pane behaviour consistent with the Filter pane behaviour), those of us who require the current pane behaviour on the right to remain as it is/was will be able to leverage the best of both worlds, or at least maintain the current behaviour if preferable.
As mentioned before, I understand the drive to make all Microsoft apps behave the same, but in this instance there's a very purposeful reason (or set of reasons) behind the difference of experience in Power BI. The 'single pane' concept is simply not useful or appropriate for many users of Power BI, and for those that do find it to be useful/an improvement, both sets of users can be accounted for by simply providing the choice between the old/new experience.
The on-object interaction itself is a nice feature to have available, but the current Filter pane style behaviour for many users is a necessity for all panes (and thanks again for all of the positive changes so far, I look forward to hopefully being given the [permanent] choice to disable the 'new pane behaviour' in the near future).
Appreciate the detailed feedback. The flexibility for the menus to work in multiple ways to address the needs of our current users are coming soon. There is a lot of work and the incremental releases are necessary so we don't wait until the feature is finished to release. More menu options we will be releasing in our Sept and Oct releases. I'm hopeful that the releases will help with what you are describing, but if they don't please let me know.
I agree with you when you say we should be able to opt-in/out on pane's behavior, because sometimes I'm working on my laptop and it would be great to have more screen area, so collapsing the panes is a must.
But when I'm working from home, connected to my widescreen monitor, I really enjoy having all the panes at sight, in order to be able to check the measures applied to a given visual or just to comfortably sway from a feature to another seamlessly.
I feel that this "choose your pane" mode is quite limitating yet viable when we have a small screen, however it should not be the only option.
Thank you for the feedback. Please stay tune for the Sept and Oct releases. You'll have more flexibility working with the menus after that. You don't want you to only have one way of working with the new menus. We will continue to release incrementally until the feature is completed.
Check out the November 2023 Power BI update to learn about new features.
Read the latest Fabric Community announcements, including updates on Power BI, Synapse, Data Factory and Data Activator.
130+ sessions, 130+ speakers, Product managers, MVPs, and experts. All about Power BI and Fabric. Attend online or watch the recordings.