Forum Discussion

anileshknpowerb's avatar
anileshknpowerb
Helper III
6 years ago

Reference vs Duplicate vs Calculated Table

Hello Experts,

I have a table SalesFact and I need to join 2 Dates, i,e, ShipDate and OrderDate.

 

What is the better approach to handle this? And why is the approach is better?

 

1. Duplicate the Date Dimension in power Query Editor for OrderDate..

2. Create reference of Date Dimension in Power Query Editor for OrderDate.

3. In the modeling Tab, Use the "New table" option like below

    NewTable = DimOrderDate

 

Thanks,

Anilesh

Need Help

4 Replies

  • vanessafvg's avatar
    vanessafvg
    Community Champion
    6 years ago

    use the same date dimension for both dates but one will be inactive and other active, and then you need to use the userelationship() function 

     

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sONvctPlplY   this video explains well

     

    so just as you would use a role playing dimension in tradition kimball star schema (dont know if that makes sense), you can do the same in power bi, you just need to utilise the above function.

    • anileshknpowerb's avatar
      anileshknpowerb
      Helper III
      6 years ago

      I want to show OderDate and ShipDate as separate dates so that users can do adhoc analysis on both dates. In that case, which one I should go with?

      • v-yingjl's avatar
        v-yingjl
        Community Support
        6 years ago

        Hi anileshknpowerb ,

         

        If you just want to show it as separate dates, you can use Duplicate to try. To do some analysis, you may use some relationships like @ vanessafvg mentioned previously.

         

        Best Regards,
        Yingjie Li

        If this post helps then please consider Accept it as the solution to help the other members find it more quickly.

  • v-yingjl's avatar
    v-yingjl
    Community Support
    6 years ago

    Hi anileshknpowerb ,

    1. Duplicate a table means copy the same previous table but if you have some new actions about the previous fact table, it will not be affected, it has benn an independent table.
    2. Reference means the table will be affected by the previous fact table. When a query references a second query, it's as though the steps in the second query are combined with, and run before, the steps in the first query. You can refer this document: Referencing Power Query queries . 
    3. Calculated tables let you add new tables based on data you've already loaded into the model. Instead of querying and loading values into your new table's columns from a data source, you create a Data Analysis Expressions (DAX) formula to define the table's values. Please refer this document: Create calculated tables in Power BI Desktop 

    In conclusion, Duplicate is generally used when you would like to create a similar query and you do not want to type the same code. Reference in Query means you would like to use that Query results in some other queries where your original query remains as a base Query and it can be used in other queries for the further processing. 

     

    In addition, this viedo and article explain the difference between Duplicate and Reference in details that you can refer: 

    1. Difference between duplicate and reference a query in Power Query 
    2. Reference vs Duplicate in Power BI 

     

    Best Regards,
    Yingjie Li

    If this post helps then please consider Accept it as the solution to help the other members find it more quickly.