Forum Discussion

Anonymous

Not applicable

6 years ago

Solved

Double lookup for value

Heya, I have the following data sets: Measured: ID Pressurein(a) Tempin(k) PressureOut(a) Tempout(k) 1 61,01325 283,15 101,01325 328,15 2 66,01325 288,15 106,01325 333,1...

Need Help

Anonymous

6 years ago

The problem i had could be tackeled by using these:

VAR lookupinlaattemplower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)] < inlaattemp))

VAR lookupinlaatdruklower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)] < inlaatdruk))

And to lookup with double value:

VAR isentropeinlaatlowertemplowerdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupinlaattemplower;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupinlaatdruklower)

For people looking to do bilinear interpolation this is my final solution:

isentropecoefficient = 
//Declaring variables.
VAR inlaattemp = SELECTEDVALUE('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaattemp(k)])
VAR uitlaattemp = SELECTEDVALUE('Gemeten parameters'[Uitlaattemp(k)])
VAR inlaatdruk = SELECTEDVALUE('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaatdruk(a)])
VAR uitlaatdruk = SELECTEDVALUE('Gemeten parameters'[Uitlaatdruk(a)])

//Stappen in tabel 
VAR deltax = 5
VAR deltay = 5

//Calculating values in lookuptable lower then measured value.
//Inlaat
VAR lookupinlaattemplower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)] < inlaattemp))
VAR lookupinlaatdruklower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)] < inlaatdruk))

//Uitlaat
VAR lookupuitlaattemplower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)] < uitlaattemp))
VAR lookupuitlaatdruklower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)] < uitlaatdruk))

//Calculating values in lookuptable higher then measured value.
//Inlaat
VAR lookupinlaattemphigher = CALCULATE(
    MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)] > inlaattemp))
VAR lookupinlaatdrukhigher = CALCULATE(
    MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)] > inlaatdruk))

//Uitlaat
VAR lookupuitlaattemphigher = CALCULATE(
    MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)] > uitlaattemp))
VAR lookupuitlaatdrukhigher = CALCULATE(
    MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)] > uitlaatdruk))

//Looking up the isentrope in lookup table.
//Inlaat
VAR isentropeinlaatlowertemplowerdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupinlaattemplower;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupinlaatdruklower)
VAR isentropeinlaatlowertemphigherdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupinlaattemplower;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupinlaatdrukhigher)
VAR isentropeinlaathighertemplowerdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupinlaattemphigher;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupinlaatdruklower)
VAR isentropeinlaathighertemphigherdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupinlaattemphigher;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupinlaatdrukhigher)

//Uitlaat
VAR isentropeuitlaatlowertemplowerdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupuitlaattemplower;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupuitlaatdruklower)
VAR isentropeuitlaatlowertemphigherdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupuitlaattemplower;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupuitlaatdrukhigher)
VAR isentropeuitlaathighertemplowerdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupuitlaattemphigher;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupuitlaatdruklower)
VAR isentropeuitlaathighertemphigherdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupuitlaattemphigher;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupuitlaatdrukhigher)

//X1_VAL = lowerdruk Y1_VAL = lowertemp
//F11 = lowertemplowerdruk F21= lowertemphigherdruk  F12= highertemplowerdruk F22=highertemphigherdruk
VAR inlaatG1 = ((lookupinlaatdruklower + deltax - inlaatdruk) * isentropeinlaatlowertemplowerdruk + (inlaatdruk - lookupinlaatdruklower) * isentropeinlaatlowertemphigherdruk) / deltax
VAR inlaatG2 = ((lookupinlaatdruklower + deltax - inlaatdruk) * isentropeinlaathighertemplowerdruk + (inlaatdruk - lookupinlaatdruklower) * isentropeinlaathighertemphigherdruk) / deltax

VAR Interpolate_BL = ((lookupinlaattemplower + deltay - inlaattemp) * inlaatG1 + (inlaattemp - lookupinlaattemplower) * inlaatG2) / deltay

RETURN
//Checking if pressure is in bound.
    IF(
        OR(
            MAX('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaatdruk(a)]) < MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);  MIN('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaatdruk(a)]) > MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)])) ;"Error Druk valt niet binnen lookup table.";

//Checking if temperature is in bound. 
    IF(
        OR(
            MAX('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaattemp(k)]) < MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]); MIN('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaattemp(k)]) > MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]));"Error Temperatuur valt niet binnen lookup table";

//Rest van code            
Interpolate_BL
    )
    )

kentyler

Solution Sage

6 years ago

Looking up values in the next/previous row is a problem because power bi does not do it natively.

However, there is a standard way to do it. This depends on having a sequential index column, which you have in your ID column.

1. store the value of the ID column in the current row in a variable, using SELECTEDVALUE

VAR cur_id = SELECTEDVALUE(measured[ID])

2. add or subtract one from cur_id, depending on whether you want next/previous

3. use LOOKUPVALUE() to look up the value in the column you want with the new id value as a criteria

you could also use FILTER() to return the value in the column you want, since it will return only the 1 row that matches the new id value.

I'm a personal Power Bi Trainer I learn something every time I answer a question. I blog at http://powerbithehardparts.com/

The Golden Rules for Power BI

Use a Calendar table. A custom Date tables is preferable to using the automatic date/time handling capabilities of Power BI. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FxiAYGbCfAQ
Build your data model as a Star Schema. Creating a star schema in Power BI is the best practice to improve performance and more importantly, to ensure accurate results! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Kilya6aUQw
Use a small set up sample data when developing. When building your measures and calculated columns always use a small amount of sample data so that it will be easier to confirm that you are getting the right numbers.
Store all your intermediate calculations in VARs when you’re writing measures. You can return these intermediate VARs instead of your final result to check on your steps along the way.

Anonymous

Not applicable

6 years ago

kentyler
Thanks, but im not quite sure you understand what i mean.

The lookup table has no id's.

In case of storing i could store the selected ID, Temperature and pressure (1, 283 and 61)
Then i would have to lookup the closes value of Temperature BELOW 283 and the one ABOVE 283 (280 and 285 in the example)
Same for Pressure.

Then i need to use the Below values to get a number (1,343) and the above numbers to get the value (1.354) i believe this could be achieved with a filter statement indeed.

My problem lays in finding the closest value above and below.

Anonymous

Not applicable

6 years ago

Wait its actually pretty easy!

If i use:

CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)] < inlaattemp))

I could use the same with MIN and a > filter. You guys helped me very well 🙂

I now have the Higher and lower values and im going to try to filter out the Isentrope

Thanks again!

(i will post my full solution for Bilinear Interpolation when im fully done in this topic for other people to find)

Anonymous

Not applicable

6 years ago

The problem i had could be tackeled by using these:

VAR lookupinlaattemplower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)] < inlaattemp))

VAR lookupinlaatdruklower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)] < inlaatdruk))

And to lookup with double value:

VAR isentropeinlaatlowertemplowerdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupinlaattemplower;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupinlaatdruklower)

For people looking to do bilinear interpolation this is my final solution:

isentropecoefficient = 
//Declaring variables.
VAR inlaattemp = SELECTEDVALUE('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaattemp(k)])
VAR uitlaattemp = SELECTEDVALUE('Gemeten parameters'[Uitlaattemp(k)])
VAR inlaatdruk = SELECTEDVALUE('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaatdruk(a)])
VAR uitlaatdruk = SELECTEDVALUE('Gemeten parameters'[Uitlaatdruk(a)])

//Stappen in tabel 
VAR deltax = 5
VAR deltay = 5

//Calculating values in lookuptable lower then measured value.
//Inlaat
VAR lookupinlaattemplower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)] < inlaattemp))
VAR lookupinlaatdruklower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)] < inlaatdruk))

//Uitlaat
VAR lookupuitlaattemplower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)] < uitlaattemp))
VAR lookupuitlaatdruklower = CALCULATE(
    MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)] < uitlaatdruk))

//Calculating values in lookuptable higher then measured value.
//Inlaat
VAR lookupinlaattemphigher = CALCULATE(
    MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)] > inlaattemp))
VAR lookupinlaatdrukhigher = CALCULATE(
    MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)] > inlaatdruk))

//Uitlaat
VAR lookupuitlaattemphigher = CALCULATE(
    MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)] > uitlaattemp))
VAR lookupuitlaatdrukhigher = CALCULATE(
    MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);
    FILTER(ALL('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)] > uitlaatdruk))

//Looking up the isentrope in lookup table.
//Inlaat
VAR isentropeinlaatlowertemplowerdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupinlaattemplower;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupinlaatdruklower)
VAR isentropeinlaatlowertemphigherdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupinlaattemplower;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupinlaatdrukhigher)
VAR isentropeinlaathighertemplowerdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupinlaattemphigher;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupinlaatdruklower)
VAR isentropeinlaathighertemphigherdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupinlaattemphigher;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupinlaatdrukhigher)

//Uitlaat
VAR isentropeuitlaatlowertemplowerdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupuitlaattemplower;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupuitlaatdruklower)
VAR isentropeuitlaatlowertemphigherdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupuitlaattemplower;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupuitlaatdrukhigher)
VAR isentropeuitlaathighertemplowerdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupuitlaattemphigher;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupuitlaatdruklower)
VAR isentropeuitlaathighertemphigherdruk = LOOKUPVALUE('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[IsentropeCoefficient];'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)];lookupuitlaattemphigher;'Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)];lookupuitlaatdrukhigher)

//X1_VAL = lowerdruk Y1_VAL = lowertemp
//F11 = lowertemplowerdruk F21= lowertemphigherdruk  F12= highertemplowerdruk F22=highertemphigherdruk
VAR inlaatG1 = ((lookupinlaatdruklower + deltax - inlaatdruk) * isentropeinlaatlowertemplowerdruk + (inlaatdruk - lookupinlaatdruklower) * isentropeinlaatlowertemphigherdruk) / deltax
VAR inlaatG2 = ((lookupinlaatdruklower + deltax - inlaatdruk) * isentropeinlaathighertemplowerdruk + (inlaatdruk - lookupinlaatdruklower) * isentropeinlaathighertemphigherdruk) / deltax

VAR Interpolate_BL = ((lookupinlaattemplower + deltay - inlaattemp) * inlaatG1 + (inlaattemp - lookupinlaattemplower) * inlaatG2) / deltay

RETURN
//Checking if pressure is in bound.
    IF(
        OR(
            MAX('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaatdruk(a)]) < MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)]);  MIN('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaatdruk(a)]) > MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Druk(a)])) ;"Error Druk valt niet binnen lookup table.";

//Checking if temperature is in bound. 
    IF(
        OR(
            MAX('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaattemp(k)]) < MIN('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]); MIN('Gemeten parameters'[Inlaattemp(k)]) > MAX('Isentrope coefficient(k)'[Temp(k)]));"Error Temperatuur valt niet binnen lookup table";

//Rest van code            
Interpolate_BL
    )
    )

Forum Discussion

Double lookup for value

Related content

Lookup rank value?

Lookup value

Lookup help

lookup value in another column

find the double interpolation value