Forum Discussion
DAX Help - Circular Dependency
- 6 months ago
Basically, what is happening here:
“To calculate A I need B, but to calculate B I need A.”
That creates a loop — and DAX does not allow loops in calculated columns.
Proposed solution:
DIVIDE(
Market Share :=
DIVIDE(
SUM(CustomerModelShare[Total Cust Model Build]),
SUM(CustomerModelShare[Total Cust Build])
)
Cust Monthly Model Build :=
IF(
SELECTEDVALUE(CustomerModelShare[Truck Category]) = "CL8",
SUM(CustomerModelShare[Cust Mthly Build]) * [Market Share]
)Now there is:
- No column referencing another column
- No row-by-row dependency
- No circular logic
You created a loop in stored columns.
Move the logic to measures and let Power BI calculate it dynamically.If this helps, ✓ Mark as Kudos | Mark as Solution| Help Others
- 6 months ago
You’re getting the circular dependency because you’re mixing calculated columns that depend on other calculated columns which (directly or indirectly) depend back on the first one.
Market share and “monthly model build” are aggregations and should typically be measures anyway.
Market Share = DIVIDE( [Total Cust Model Build], [Total Cust Build] ) Total Cust Model Build = SUM ( CustomerModelShare[Total Cust Model Build] ) Total Cust Build = SUM ( CustomerModelShare[Total Cust Build] ) Cust Monthly Model Build := IF( SELECTEDVALUE(CustomerModelShare[Truck Category]) = "CL8", [Cust Mthly Build] * [Market Share], BLANK() ) Cust Mthly Build = SUM ( CustomerModelShare[Cust Mthly Build] )
Can you please show us how is your model build? how are the tables related each other.
I have the total for the year for all customers 265,000. I have the MS high level for each Customer, 41.5%
I have what the customers volume is total for the year across all products, 109,975.
I have the products MS, now I want to use the product MS to calculate the month product volume
Sorry if not making alot of sense.
Thank you,