Forum Discussion

Anonymous's avatar
Anonymous
Not applicable
8 years ago
Solved

Calculated column

Greetings,

 

Tables:

 

2016 Rebate
2017 Rebate
sales

 

I have this this Calculated column:

 

Rebate 2016b = CALCULATE(
SUMx(
Filter(
sales,
sales[year]=2016),
sales[Rebatable]*related('2016 Rebate'[Percent%])))

 

When I attempt to replicate it to access 2017 Values:

 

Rebate 2017b = CALCULATE(
SUMx(
Filter(
sales,
sales[year]=2017),
sales[Rebatable]*related('2017 Rebate'[percent])))

 

I get this error regarding circular dependency:

 

A circular dependency was detected: sales[Rebate 2017b], sales[Rebate 2016b], sales[Rebate 2017b].

 

Can you point me to the error of my ways???

 

Regards,

 

  • Hi Anonymous,

     

    I'd suggest one of two ways to work around this error:

     

    (1) rewrite the calculated columns to remove the CALCULATE:

       Rebate 2016b = IF( sales[year]=2016,  sales[Rebatable] * related('2016 Rebate'[Percent%]) )

       Rebate 2017b = IF( sales[year]=2017,  sales[Rebatable] * related('2017 Rebate'[Percent%]) )

    , or

    (2)  remove these calculated columns from the Sales table and change them into measures.

     

     

     

     

2 Replies

  • Hi Anonymous,

     

    I'd suggest one of two ways to work around this error:

     

    (1) rewrite the calculated columns to remove the CALCULATE:

       Rebate 2016b = IF( sales[year]=2016,  sales[Rebatable] * related('2016 Rebate'[Percent%]) )

       Rebate 2017b = IF( sales[year]=2017,  sales[Rebatable] * related('2017 Rebate'[Percent%]) )

    , or

    (2)  remove these calculated columns from the Sales table and change them into measures.

     

     

     

     

    • Anonymous's avatar
      Anonymous
      Not applicable

      Thank you - lots to learn, often quoted

       

      "DAX is simple, but it is not easy!"

       

      Best