2 Bookmarks on 1 Tab with different visuals

I have 1 tab with 2 bookmarks which uses a visual to toggle between them.

Bookmark Open:

Visual A

Visual B

Bookmark Closed:

Visual C

Visual E

When someone clicks Open they get the visuals on the open bookmark, closed they get the visuals on the closed bookmark.

I'm trying to create a new visual on Bookmark Open however it also is showing up on Bookmark Closed. When I delete it from Bookmark closed, it deletes from both bookmarks. What am I missing?