Forum Discussion

Databasic's avatar
Databasic
Regular Visitor
1 year ago
Solved

Model relationships breaking unexpectedly when visualizing Planning table columns in Power BI

Hi

We are going to change ERP system and I have to alter my data so we can upload it in the right format to our ERP system.

Here’s my current setup:

  • All relevant columns are formatted as Text via Power Query.

  • I use a central Name table, which contains unique rows per 4-digit-code.

  • This code links both to Planning and RM_Film via bidirectional one-to-many relationships (Name is on the "one" side).

  • There are no blanks or mismatches—codes are clean.

Additionally:

  • I created a small Fixed table with static values, joined to Name using an Index column.

  • I use calculated columns like this:

GEWEI =

VAR Unit = RELATED('Name'[MEINS])
RETURN
SWITCH(
        Unit,
        "KG", "Kg",
 "M2", "G",
         BLANK()
    )

I’m trying to build a table visual containing selected columns from Name, RM_Film, and Planning, structured to match our ERP import format. It needs to be dynamic so we can run multiple simular reports when we test our ERP.

What’s baffling:

  • Initially, making the relationships bidirectional solved the problem and let me build the table as expected.
  • Later, after adding more columns (incl. calculated columns), the same error returned: “relationship not found” when pulling anything from Planning.
  • I rolled back by removing those columns—but the error persisted.
  • I even recreated the entire file and again reached a point where the visual worked—until I added a Planning column and it broke, although the relationships hadn’t changed.
  • Everything else seems stable. The same issue doesn't happen when I build a separate visual with just Planning and Name.

What it should look like
CLASS_01DWERKVERSGKTGRMMTPOSMTVFPTRAGRLADGRPRCTRSTAWNMTVERHERKLHERKREKGRPEKWSL
FPFILMBE401YYNORMF111GC-AAV481159001BE B10A002
FPPAPBE401YYNORMF111GC-AAV480255151DE B10A002

Reason why I don't use Power Query in Excel:

  • Our database server runs Excel 2010, which lacks modern Power Query features.

  • I prefer to visualize and manage relationships transparently in Power BI.

  • It worked yesterday—and now it doesn’t. I’d love insight into what could be causing this inconsistency.

Any help or ideas would be amazing. Thanks!

Need Help
  • rajendraongole1's avatar
    rajendraongole1
    1 year ago

    Hi Databasic  - Only keep Name → Planning and Name → RM_Film relationships as single-directional (one-to-many, from Name to Planning/RM_Film). That’s usually safest.

     

    When both are set to bidirectional, Power BI may struggle to resolve filter propagation, especially when you try to pull data into a single visual that includes columns from all three tables errors like , ambiguous filter paths. Avoid bidirectional joins unless truly needed.

    suggest you, make them single-direction from Name → Planning and Name → RM_Film.Use that table for your ERP export visuals/reports — reliable and isolated from model quirks.If needed, use slicers from Name or Fixed tables to make dynamic test versions.

    Bidirectional relationships and ambiguity in DAX - SQLBI

     

    Hope this helps.

     

     

3 Replies

  • rajendraongole1's avatar
    rajendraongole1
    Icon for Super User rankSuper User
    1 year ago

    Hi Databasic  - Only keep Name → Planning and Name → RM_Film relationships as single-directional (one-to-many, from Name to Planning/RM_Film). That’s usually safest.

     

    When both are set to bidirectional, Power BI may struggle to resolve filter propagation, especially when you try to pull data into a single visual that includes columns from all three tables errors like , ambiguous filter paths. Avoid bidirectional joins unless truly needed.

    suggest you, make them single-direction from Name → Planning and Name → RM_Film.Use that table for your ERP export visuals/reports — reliable and isolated from model quirks.If needed, use slicers from Name or Fixed tables to make dynamic test versions.

    Bidirectional relationships and ambiguity in DAX - SQLBI

     

    Hope this helps.

     

     

    • Databasic's avatar
      Databasic
      Regular Visitor
      1 year ago

      This web page gave me the right understanding of relations to troubleshoot. I had to dive into the data and was able to pull out some duplicates to remove the indirect many to many relation. Resolved, thanks a lot 💪

  • v-pnaroju-msft's avatar
    v-pnaroju-msft
    Icon for Community Support rankCommunity Support
    1 year ago

    Thankyou, rajendraongole1, for your response.

    Hi Databasic,

    We appreciate your question on the Microsoft Fabric Community Forum.

    Based on my understanding of the issue, please find attached a screenshot and a sample PBIX file that may assist in resolving the matter:

    We hope the information provided helps to resolve the issue.
    Should you have any further queries, kindly feel free to contact the Microsoft Fabric community.

    Thank you.