ArcGIS map cuts off points after adding a tooltip

I'm trying to plot this data onto an ArcGIS map. When I drag just the latitude and longitude columns into the fields to use, it looks as I'm expecting: 

However, when I drag the "Price" column onto the "Tooltip" field, all of a sudden it fails to plot every point whose latitude (or maybe it's longitude...) is above a certain value: 

What could be causing this? I know some visuals have upper limits on the number of rows of data it can display, but this shouldn't be being changed just by simply adding a column to the Tooltip field, right?