Forum Discussion

ClaudioF's avatar
ClaudioF
Helper II
1 year ago
Solved

combinatorics in dinamic dax

Hello guys, i have posted here so many times about getting a logic right, but i just noticed it was impossible, in the way i was thinking, no one could help me.

I have a new aproach of how to get the desired result, its by using combinatorics, of course, i need to know if its even possible in the dax.

I have the image bellow that shows how the combinations might work, and ahead i also have the code i'm trying, its not working properly and i would like some help with it.

 

In this code, the objective is have at the end the combinations that attend to the condition that the amount of concatenated orders is the highest and the sum of values are <= 21.

 

Obs. this code might work with many different products, but to this example i just used one.

Code:

 

FinalCorrectStatus =
VAR CurrentItem = SELECTEDVALUE('DB_ORDERS'[Produto])
VAR OrdersTable = FILTER(ALL('DB_ORDERS'), 'DB_ORDERS'[Produto] = CurrentItem)

VAR OrderCombinations =
ADDCOLUMNS(
GENERATEALL(
OrdersTable,
SUMMARIZE(
OrdersTable,
'DB_ORDERS'[Pedido],
"Soma_Quant_Falta", SUM('DB_ORDERS'[QT. falt])
)
),
"PedidosConcatenados", CONCATENATEX(OrdersTable, 'DB_ORDERS'[Pedido], ", "),
"Qtd_Pedidos", COUNTROWS(OrdersTable) -- Conta o número de pedidos na combinação
)

VAR FilteredCombinations =
FILTER(OrderCombinations, [Soma_Quant_Falta] <= 21)

VAR MaxPedidos = MAXX(FilteredCombinations, [Qtd_Pedidos]) -- Encontra o maior número de pedidos

VAR BestCombination =
FILTER(FilteredCombinations, [Qtd_Pedidos] = MaxPedidos) -- Mantém apenas a combinação com mais pedidos

RETURN BestCombination

 

Can anyone please help me with it?

advanced dax
data engineering
DAX
Help
matrix
SUMMARIZE
  • ClaudioF's avatar
    ClaudioF
    1 year ago

    didnt work.. i think its not even possible though, i am thinking about changing to python completlty in order to achieve this result i need

5 Replies

  • VahidDM's avatar
    VahidDM
    Super User
    1 year ago

    Hi ClaudioF 

     

    Try this:

    BestCombination =
VAR CurrentProduct = SELECTEDVALUE('DB_ORDERS'[Produto])

VAR OrdersTable =
    FILTER(
        ALL('DB_ORDERS'),
        'DB_ORDERS'[Produto] = CurrentProduct
    )

VAR AllCombos =
    GENERATE(
        OrdersTable,
        FILTER(
            OrdersTable,
            'DB_ORDERS'[Pedido] <= EARLIER('DB_ORDERS'[Pedido])
        )
    )

VAR CombosWithSum =
    ADDCOLUMNS(
        AllCombos,
        "PedidosConcatenados", CONCATENATEX(
            FILTER(
                OrdersTable,
                'DB_ORDERS'[Pedido] <= EARLIER('DB_ORDERS'[Pedido])
            ),
            'DB_ORDERS'[Pedido],
            ", ",
            'DB_ORDERS'[Pedido], ASC
        ),
        "Soma_Quant_Falta", SUMX(
            FILTER(
                OrdersTable,
                'DB_ORDERS'[Pedido] <= EARLIER('DB_ORDERS'[Pedido])
            ),
            'DB_ORDERS'[QT. falt]
        ),
        "Qtd_Pedidos", COUNTROWS(
            FILTER(
                OrdersTable,
                'DB_ORDERS'[Pedido] <= EARLIER('DB_ORDERS'[Pedido])
            )
        )
    )

VAR FilteredCombos =
    FILTER(
        CombosWithSum,
        [Soma_Quant_Falta] <= 21
    )

VAR MaxQtdPedidos =
    MAXX(FilteredCombos, [Qtd_Pedidos])

VAR BestComboFinal =
    TOPN(
        1,
        FILTER(FilteredCombos, [Qtd_Pedidos] = MaxQtdPedidos),
        [Soma_Quant_Falta], DESC
    )

RETURN
    CONCATENATEX(
        BestComboFinal,
        [PedidosConcatenados],
        "; "
    )

     

    Generate combinations by comparing each order to orders with equal or lower numbers to simplify calculations.
    Calculate the sum (Soma_Quant_Falta) and count (Qtd_Pedidos) for each combination.
    Filter only combinations whose sum is <= 21.
    Pick the combination with the maximum number of orders (Qtd_Pedidos).
    Finally, concatenate the order numbers clearly for display.

    If this post helps, please consider accepting it as the solution to help the other members find it more quickly.

    Appreciate your Kudos!! 

     

    LinkedIn|Twitter|Blog |YouTube 

    • ClaudioF's avatar
      ClaudioF
      Helper II
      1 year ago

      Hey there! thankyou for your return;

      This code you provided is generating an error: The GENERATE function does not allow two columns with the same name "DB_ORDERS"[Cliente]. i got this same problem in other attempts..

      • VahidDM's avatar
        VahidDM
        Super User
        1 year ago

        You right 🙂
        Try this:

        BestCombination =
VAR CurrentProduct = SELECTEDVALUE('DB_ORDERS'[Produto])

VAR OrdersTable =
    FILTER(
        ALL('DB_ORDERS'),
        'DB_ORDERS'[Produto] = CurrentProduct
    )

VAR OrdersDistinct =
    SELECTCOLUMNS(
        OrdersTable,
        "Pedido", 'DB_ORDERS'[Pedido],
        "QT_falt", 'DB_ORDERS'[QT. falt]
    )

VAR Combos =
    GENERATE(
        OrdersDistinct,
        FILTER(
            OrdersDistinct,
            [Pedido] <= EARLIER([Pedido])
        )
    )

VAR ComboSummary =
    ADDCOLUMNS(
        Combos,
        "PedidosConcatenados",
            CONCATENATEX(
                FILTER(OrdersDistinct, [Pedido] <= EARLIER([Pedido])),
                [Pedido],
                ", ",
                [Pedido], ASC
            ),
        "Soma_Quant_Falta",
            SUMX(
                FILTER(OrdersDistinct, [Pedido] <= EARLIER([Pedido])),
                [QT_falt]
            ),
        "Qtd_Pedidos",
            COUNTROWS(
                FILTER(OrdersDistinct, [Pedido] <= EARLIER([Pedido]))
            )
    )

VAR FilteredCombos =
    FILTER(
        ComboSummary,
        [Soma_Quant_Falta] <= 21
    )

VAR MaxQtdPedidos =
    MAXX(FilteredCombos, [Qtd_Pedidos])

VAR BestCombo =
    TOPN(
        1,
        FILTER(FilteredCombos, [Qtd_Pedidos] = MaxQtdPedidos),
        [Soma_Quant_Falta], DESC
    )

RETURN
    CONCATENATEX(
        BestCombo,
        [PedidosConcatenados],
        "; "
    )